As the thread title indicates, I am nearing the point where I get to pick my legendary cloak from the quartet on offer courtesy of the generous world boss. Yes, I only started with AoC sometime last year.
Now the question is which one to pick, seeing as I play almost exclusively PvE content. The two viable candidates to me seem to be
Conversant Mantle of the Living Legend
Slayer's Mantle of the Living Legend
however I find it very difficult to evaluate whether 45 combat rating are worth more than 15 hit rating, 2 critical damage rating and 73 offhand rating. In case of a tie I guess the 22 hate decrease on the Slayer's Mantle would be the tie breaker.
Or asking more generally, have agreed upon stat weights been theory crafted that would tell how valuable each DPS stat is compared to each other? Even the Damage for Dummies thread is a bit vague on how exactly offhand attacks work.